Godzilla Minus One (Godzilla Store Exclusive) (4K UHD Review)

• Reviewed by: Stephen Bjork
• Review Date: Sep 18, 2024
• Format: 4K Ultra HD
• 

Director

Takashi Yamazaki

Release Date(s)

2023 (September 3, 2024)

Studio(s)

Toho Studios/Robot Communications (Toho)

• Film/Program Grade: A-
• Video Grade: A
• Audio Grade: A+
• Extras Grade: A
• Overall Grade: A+

Review

[Editor's Note: This was a Godzilla Store site exclusive that contained English subtitles, but it appears to have gone out of print and the listing has been taken down. However, standard Blu-ray, 4K Ultra HD, and 4K Steelbook releases with English audio and subtitles are coming to the US on November 19th. Also still available are the original Blu-ray, 4K Ultra HD, and 4K Steelbook Japanese imports, minus English language options.]

Godzilla Minus One (aka Gojira Mainasu Wan) has become a genuine phenomenon even in America, where it quickly became the highest-grossing Japanese language film of all time. That’s impressive by any metric, especially for the 30th live action installment in a seventy-year-old franchise. While Godzilla movies can be a little divisive, with everyone having their own favorites, the reaction to Godzilla Minus One has been uniformly positive. It’s been something of a revelation to many people, which is interesting considering that it’s undeniably derivative of all the films that came before it. The genius of writer/director Takashi Yamazaki is that he took all those familiar elements and combined them in a way that manages to feel fresh, even to hardened fans of the franchise. It’s more of a refinement than a revelation, and where Godzilla Minus One really shines is in its execution rather than its conception. Yet the key to making all of that work is still a conceptual choice on the part of Toho and Yamazaki.

When Toho rebooted the entire franchise in 1984 with The Return of Godzilla, it did so by effectively erasing all of the Shōwa era sequels and offering a direct sequel to the 1954 Godzilla instead. The rest of the Heisei era films followed that new continuity. When Toho performed another reboot with Godzilla 2000, they once again reset everything that happened after 1954, and for a time they did that with every Millennium film that followed suit (up until Godzilla: Tokyo S.O.S., anyway, which was a direct sequel to Godzilla Against Mechagodzilla.) That offered a bit more freedom for filmmakers to pursue the stories that interested them the most—all under Toho’s watchful eye, of course. Yet when Hideaki Anno launched what would become known as the Reiwa era series with Shin Godzilla, he took the more radical step of not just disregarding all of the previous continuities, but the 1954 original as well. This new Godzilla represented the re-imagined first appearance of the King of Monsters, offering the opportunity to once again show the reaction of the Japanese people to a previously unheard-of threat. Anno also crafted the most radical alteration to Godzilla’s origins since Godzilla, Mothra, and King Ghidorah: Giant Monsters All-Out Attack.

(Brief digression for the pedantic at heart: yes, The Return of Godzilla was technically released prior to the beginning of the Heisei era, and Shin Godzilla was also released prior to the start of the Reiwa era. Yet both films have been grandfathered into the eras that followed, and if that doesn’t bother anyone in Japan, it shouldn’t bother you.)

Godzilla Minus One does something similar to Shin Godzilla, but by taking the additional step of a giant leap backwards to before 1954. It’s another standalone origin story, yet it still honors the films that preceded it in a way that Anno’s film didn’t. In a nutshell, Godzilla Minus One is the 1954 Godzilla mixed with Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah mixed with Godzilla vs. Destroyah mixed with Giant Monsters All-Out Attack mixed with an inversion of Giant Monsters All-Out Attack. To elaborate slightly: it’s the basic setting of the original Godzilla mixed with the retconned origin story of King Ghidorah mixed with the pissed-off Godzilla of Destroyah mixed with the “Japan dealing with the ghosts of what it did during WWII” of GMK mixed with an individual dealing with the ghost of what he actually didn’t do during WWII. Whew. (It even throws in a generous dose of Jaws for good measure.)

Appropriately enough, Yamazaki’s script for Godzilla Minus One opens on the fictional Odo Island, although this particular version of it has more in common with the Lagos Island of Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah. Kōichi Shikishima (Ryunosuke Kamiki) is a kamikaze pilot who puts his plane down at a repair base on Odo Island in the waning days of World War II, ostensibly because of mechanical issues, but the reality is that he can’t go through with his mission. While he’s there, the island is attacked by a small proto-Godzilla, leaving everyone at the base dead except for Shikishima and the lead mechanic Tachibana (Munetaka Aoki). Both of them end up scarred from the attack in very different ways, with Tachibana resenting Shikishima for once again failing to act. After the war ends, Shikishima ends up working on a civilian minesweeper to clear out both the Axis and the Allied mines that fill the waters around Tokyo. It’s a dangerous job, but he’s suffering from survivor’s guilt, and he feels compelled to work in order to support the woman who he lives with (Minami Hamabe) and the orphaned child that they’ve both unofficially adopted. When the U.S. nuclear testing at the Bikini Atoll reawakens and mutates Godzilla, the larger and much more powerful monster sets course for the mainland. That sets Shikishima and Tachibana on a collision course with each other once again, but this time, Shikishima will finally have to exorcise his own demons once and for all.

The way that everything resolves is predictable enough, with any potential twists being telegraphed well in advance (literally so, in one case). Again, though, it’s all about the execution. While there’s still a bit of humor in Godzilla Minus One, Yamazaki chose to eschew most of the sillier and more fantastical elements of past films in order to focus on the horrific nature of the beast (so to speak). The stakes are high, the casualties are enormous, and this particular iteration of Godzilla is playing for keeps. It’s not quite the avenging angel of Giant Monsters All-Out Attack, and Godzilla isn’t being driven by the pain of an internal meltdown like in Destroyah, but this is still one mean green mother from inner space. It’s the living embodiment of pure rage.

That appears to be the primary element of Godzilla Minus One that audiences are responding to the most: Yamazaki managed to make Godzilla scary again. That’s no mean feat, but he also muddied up the thematic waters a bit in the process. As ham-handed as Shikishima’s redemption arc may be, Godzilla ends up being a bit more enigmatic. While Operation Crossroads is still at least partly responsible for Godzilla’s (re)birth, the nuclear metaphors from Honda’s Godzilla are missing here. So are the Fukushima metaphors from Shin Godzilla, as well as the ghosts of WWII from Giant Monsters All-Out Attack. Godzilla doesn’t really represent anything in Godzilla Minus One other than perhaps a manifestation of Shikishima’s guilt, but that’s a heavy burden for an entire nation to bear on his behalf, so the metaphor becomes a bit strained. The reality is that some monsters just want to watch the world burn.

Not that there’s anything wrong with that, of course. Godzilla has proven remarkably resilient over the decades, changing with the times, and no one version of the King of Monsters can truly be considered definitive. Godzilla Minus One’s rendition is memorably malicious, and that’s good enough. Yamazaki staged some remarkable set pieces in support of that, including the Jaws-inspired minesweeper chase that’s already become the stuff of legend—it’s legitimately one of the best sequences in the entire history of the Godzilla franchise. Proving, of course, that it’s all about the execution.

Still, that execution is far from perfect in Godzilla Minus One. The digital Godzilla works reasonably well despite the limited means at Yamazaki’s disposal, but there are still a few weak spots like an awkward hitch in the walk cycle and some other animation that doesn’t scale well. There are also a few moments during the finale that strain suspension of disbelief past the breaking point, especially when a logistical nightmare that would have taken all day to execute is dispatched in a split second by a single jump cut (all while Godzilla sits beneath the waves, patiently waiting for everyone to finish). Yamazaki is guilty of exploiting a few too many narrative conveniences in order to keep the story moving, and he does rob some of the suspense by telegraphing the twists too far in advance. Those are minor quibbles, though. Godzilla fans are a tolerant lot (Roland Emmerich’s American remake notwithstanding), and they’ve grudgingly accepted a lot of worse things over the decades. Yet many of them have still longed for a darker, more serious take on the material, and Yamazaki delivered that in spades. There’s a damned good reason why Godzilla Minus One has struck such a chord worldwide: imperfect as it may be, it’s still the best representation of the Godzilla that many fans have wanted but rarely received prior to this.

Cinematographer Kōzō Shibasaki captured Godzilla Minus One digitally at resolutions up to 6K using Sony CineAlta Venice cameras with Zeiss Supreme Prime and Angénieux Optimo Ultra Lenses. Post-production work was completed as a 4K Digital Intermediate, framed at 2.39:1 for its theatrical release. Yamazaki served as both the main unit director and the visual effects supervisor, so he was directly involved at every stage of that process. Presumably he was involved with approving this 4K master as well, which has been graded in High Dynamic Range for both Dolby Vision and HDR10.

While Godzilla Minus One was eventually re-released in a black-and-white version (more on that later), it’s important to remember that it was conceived of and shot as a color film, albeit one with a muted color palette. It’s not really desaturated to any significant extent, however; it’s just that the costuming and production design favors grays, browns, and dark blues. The opening shots of Shikishima landing on Odo Island look much richer, with the green grass and the deep blue of the ocean providing more visual variety, but once Godzilla makes his first appearance, greens, reds, and even whites are at a kept at a minimum for the rest of the film. Yet those intentionally drab colors are still offset by the warm hues of the flesh tones—the environmental details of Godzilla Minus One may appear bleak, but the people don’t. Browns may dominate, but there’s a wide variety of shades of brown on display. In other words, there’s still plenty of depth to the colors, just not much breadth, and that look has been replicated perfectly in this HDR grade.

The contrast range is solid, and while the darkest shots don’t have much shadow detail, that’s likely just how they were captured. Fine detail is generally well-resolved, although it’s possible that the visual effects work was rendered at 2K and then upscaled to 4K. The abundant composite shots in the film do have a softer edge to them when compared to the relatively un-retouched live action shots. During those more intimate moments, textures like skin and costuming are all a bit sharper. There’s a very light layer of fake grain that’s been added to the image, although it may not even be visible on smaller displays (ironically enough, if Godzilla Minus One had been shot on film, some people would probably complain that too much DNR had been applied). There are no encoding artifacts or other issues of note. This is as good as Godzilla Minus One can possibly look.

Primary audio is offered in Japanese Dolby Atmos, with optional English, English SDH, Spanish, and Japanese barrier-free subtitles (which is the Japanese equivalent of SDH). It’s a wildly aggressive and highly immersive mix, and it’s not shy about advertising the fact that it’s Atmos during the opening shot when Shikishima’s plane passes over the camera and through the overhead channels. There are plenty of subtle environmental effects that also provide envelopment, like the way that rain dripping on the roofs can be heard above the viewer. Yet it’s some of the panning effects that are the most interesting. When Shikishima gets back into his plane and freezes while Godzilla passes by to the left, the sound of the monster’s growling can be heard panning overhead from the front left height channel to the rear left one, as if you’re sitting in the cockpit with him. The death and destruction that follows offers plenty of channel engagement and dynamic impact. Most of that happens in just the first few minutes of Godzilla Minus One, but it sets the stage for what follows for the rest of the film. It’s consistently immersive and exciting from beginning to end. The ambient score by Naoki Satō tends to get buried in the mix sometimes, although it’s still effective, but Akira Ifukube’s legendary fanfare and march are both front and center when they make their inevitable appearances. (There’s even a snippet of the Island theme from King Kong vs. Godzilla at one point.) The only minor disappointment is that the bass doesn’t dig as deep as it could, but there’s still enough of a low end to provide some appropriate rumble whenever Godzilla is on the rampage. That minor caveat aside, this is still a reference-quality Atmos track.

Additional audio options include 5.1 and 2.0 Dolby TrueHD, plus a Japanese 2.0 TrueHD Descriptive audio track that’s also referred to as being barrier-free. (It’s easy to appreciate the intent behind that nomenclature.)

Toho’s original Collector’s Edition release of Godzilla Minus One was intended for the Japanese market only, and per their usual policy, it didn’t offer any English subtitles. That resulted in a lot of online grumbling from English-speaking fans, but please keep in mind that they’re under no more obligation to include English subtitles on any of their releases than North American distributors are obligated to include Japanese subtitles. Sauce for the goose. Yet for once, Toho actually listened to the complaints and is now offering the same set directly from their official Godzilla Store, this time with English subtitles (although there’s still a catch for English-speaking audiences that’s been keeping the grumbling active).

Just like their previous set, Toho’s new Region-Free 4K Ultra HD Collector’s Edition release of Godzilla Minus One is a four-disc set that includes a Blu-ray with a 1080p copy of the original film, a second Blu-ray with the Minus Color re-release version, and a third Blu-ray with the bulk of the extras. They’re packaged in a fold-out case that displays a different spread of Big G on each side, doing what he does best: leveling a city. It also includes two different booklets, the first of which offers production photographs, promotional materials, and multiple essays. The second booklet is a mock vintage “Special Disaster Countermeasures” handout, showing off the various plans for dealing with a potential appearance by Godzilla. (The maps and some of the diagrams are re-creations of the ones that are seen in Godzilla Minus One.) The packaging and the booklets are nearly identical to Toho’s previous Japanese-only release, right down to the wraparound cover sheet (although that’s been modified on the bottom to reflect the American PG-13 rating). That means that most of the text is in Japanese, but note that Toho is sending purchasers a link to download a PDF of the main booklet with all of the text translated into English. That’s better than nothing.

There’s still one other catch, however, which is that the English subtitles are offered on the feature film only, not on any of the extras. That means Godzilla Minus One and Minus One/Minus Color have English subtitles on the first three discs, but none of the trailers do, and nothing on the fourth disc has any subtitles whatsoever. On the other hand, all of the menus have been redesigned to include English descriptions (note that the listings below have been updated to reflect Toho’s official translations, rather than the Google Lens translations that we had to use for our review of the Japanese set). The extras on the first two feature film discs are identical, although they’re all in 4K on the UHD and standard HD on the Blu-ray (although a few of the ones on the UHD were primarily shot in HD and then upscaled to 4K):

DISCS ONE & TWO: GODZILLA MINUS ONE (UHD & BD)

• Promo 1 (UHD – :33)
• Promo 2 (UHD – :33)
• Trailer (UHD – 1:25)
• TV Spots:
  • No. 1 (Upscaled UHD – :18)
  • This is Godzilla (UHD – :18)
  • A Ray of Hope (UHD – :18)
  • Worldwide Praise (Upscaled UHD – :18)
  • Live and Flight (UHD – :18)
  • Vs. Godzilla (UHD – :18)
• 6 Second Bumpers:
  • Kōichi Shikishima/Ryunosuke Kamiki (UHD – :09)
  • Noriko Ōishi/Minami Hamebe (UHD – :09)
  • Shirō Mizushima/Yuki Yamada (UHD – :09)
  • Sōsaku Tachibana/Munetaka Aoki (UHD – :09)
  • Kenji Noda/Hidetaka Yoshioka (UHD – :09)
  • Tatsuo Hotta/Miou Tanaka (UHD – :09)
  • Sumiko Ōta/Sakura Ando (UHD – :09)
  • Seiji Akitsu/Kuranosuke Sasaki (UHD – :09)
  • A (UHD – :09)
  • B (UHD – :09)
  • C (UHD – :09)
• IMAX PR Clip (Upscaled UHD – 1:33)
• ScreenX PR Clip (UHD – :45)
• Toho Cinemas Movie Lineup (UHD – :22)
• CineMileage Info Clip (UHD – :23)

DISC THREE: GODZILLA MINUS ONE/MINUS COLOR (BD)

• Trailer (HD – :44)

DISC FOUR: EXTRAS (BD)

• Behind the Scenes: Godzilla Minus One (HD – 65:27)
• VFX Behind the Scenes (HD – 19:26)
• Theater Release Commemorative Special Feature: Behind the Scenes: Godzilla Minus One -No.30- (HD – 22:06)
• Event Video Collection:
  • September 4, 2023: Completion Press Conference (HD – 11:37)
  • October 18, 2023 World Premiere Red Carpet Event (HD – 7:45)
  • October 23, 2023 Tokyo International Film Festival Opening Red Carpet (HD – 3:05)
  • November 1, 2023 Tokyo International Film Festival Closing Screening Stage Greeting (HD – 10:30)
  • November 3, 2023 Theatrical Release Stage Greeting (HD – 16:06)
  • November 8-10, 2023: North American Premiere (HD – 12:28)
  • November 29, 2023: Sapporo Event (HD – 6:58)
• Takashi Yamazaki Selections Talk Shows:
  • September 15, 2023 Screening Event #1 (Guest: Shinji Higuchi) (HD – 12:56)
  • September 29, 2023 Screening Event #2 (Guest: Keizo Murase) (HD – 15:45)
  • October 13, 2023 Screening Event #3 (Guest: Shusuke Kaneko) (HD – 17:03)
  • October 27, 2024 Screening Event #4 (Guest: Hideaki Anno) (HD – 18:47)
  • Academy Awards Winner Additional Screening Trailer (HD – :35)

The lack of English subtitles isn’t really an issue for the various trailers and promo spots on the first three discs because most of them are pretty self-explanatory. It’s a bit more of an obstacle with the fourth disc, although there’s still plenty of material here that’s enjoyable without them. The Behind the Scenes video offers a wealth of behind-the-scenes and on-set footage that’s fascinating regardless of language, as it clearly demonstrates what parts of any given scene were built practically and where the green screens took over. It also offers plenty of interview footage with the cast and crew, which unfortunately isn’t particularly helpful if you don’t speak Japanese. The VFX Behind the Scenes, on the other hand, are all wordless ones that demonstrate how the digital Godzilla was designed and the way that all of the layers of effects were pieced together. Behind the Scenes: Godzilla Minus One is a television special that’s really more of a puff piece to hype the film. The various Event Videos do have a few wordless red carpet events, as well as the North American premiere, none of which require subtitles. (There was a translator on hand for the American premiere.) Where the lack of subtitles hurts the most is in the four different talk show appearances by Yamazaki, not so much because of him, but rather because each of them teams him up with a different director and/or effects artist who had worked on previous Godzilla films: Shinji Higuchi, Keizo Murase, Shusuke Kaneko, and Hideaki Anno. It would have been nice to hear what they all had to say about Godzilla Minus One.

Still, all of that was the easy part. Now it’s time to rip off the Band-Aid. There’s doubtless going to be more weeping, wailing, and gnashing of teeth that Godzilla Minus One/Minus Color is only available on Blu-ray (although it’s worth noting that it offers the exact same audio options, including Dolby Atmos, as well as English subtitles). Yet the reality is that the black-and-white variant is just that: a novelty. It’s not how Godzilla Minus One was intended to be seen, and it was produced as an afterthought to capitalize on the runaway success of the initial theatrical release. Godzilla Minus One was designed in color, art directed in color, costume designed in color, captured in color, and finished in color. It’s ironic that film fans get outraged whenever a black-and-white film is colorized, but then they bend over backwards to praise a color film that’s been de-colorized. Either way, its revisionism to the original intent of the filmmakers. (Even if a given director wishes that they could have shot in black-and-white, the fact remains that they didn’t.) If it’s wrong to alter a film from its original intent, then it’s still wrong even when we like the results. You can’t have it both ways.

It’s also nearly impossible to re-create the look of black-and-white film accurately by desaturating color, especially digitally captured color. While Godzilla Minus One/Minus Color was color corrected for black-and-white on a shot-by-shot basis, much of it is flat and lacking in contrast due to the fact that the different colors as originally captured end up looking monotonal after being desaturated. It certainly doesn’t look anything like Masao Tamai’s stark, high-contrast cinematography for the original 1954 Godzilla. The idea of this version of Godzilla Minus One trying to evoke the feel of that film doesn’t really work anyway due to the fact that it’s widescreen 2.39:1. The original was at the full-frame Academy aperture of 1.37:1. Toho wouldn’t start using anamorphic Tohoscope lenses until 1957, and while they did release films in widescreen black-and-white, all of the widescreen Godzilla installments were in full color. And since Godzilla Minus One is set earlier during the earlier period from 1945-1947, the ‘Scope imagery feels especially anachronistic. Having recently watched the original Godzilla projected in native 4K from Toho’s Japanese UHD release of the film, I can vouch for the fact that Godzilla Minus One/Minus Color doesn’t replicate the same look and feel. The reality is that Godzilla Minus One/Minus Color looks just fine on Blu-ray, and it’s appropriate to think of it as being part of the extras. It’s definitely not the best way to experience Godzilla Minus One for the first time.

Still, if you want to have Minus One/Minus Color as a part of your collection, this set may be your only option. The same thing is true of the extras, with or without subtitles. Toho has already announced the standard release of Godzilla Minus One on 4K, and it’s a two-disc set that in all likelihood will only include the first two discs from this set. (We’ll update this once we confirm that fact.) That means that if you’re holding out in the hopes that Toho will offer the extras here with English subtitles on a future release, you’re probably going to be disappointed. Maybe they’ll eventually offer a standalone Blu-ray release of Minus One/Minus Color, but there’s no guarantee that’s going to happen either. Regardless, this a fantastic release that’s worth owning despite the lack of subtitles for the extras. It’s not cheap, but it still costs a lot less than importing the Japanese disc does, and that doesn’t have English subtitles at all. The packaging alone is simply gorgeous. It’s the best set that Toho has ever produced for any of their Godzilla films, and it gets the highest possible recommendation.

- Stephen Bjork

(You can follow Stephen on social media at these links: Twitter, Facebook, and Letterboxd).